IKEA shelves packaged with minimal waste, no word on adhesives

We are sprucing up our living room, and in the process of looking for a good storage solution, saw a little blurb mentioning some IKEA shelves in, of all places, Better Homes & Gardens magazine.

After a bit more research, we decided that even with shipping costs (Colorado’s IKEA store is still on the drawing boards), the shelves were a good value (and a great place to invest the money from a small bonus for Mr. Cheap and the sale of our treadmill). We ordered them and waited.

In a couple of weeks, the shelves arrived at our door. They were delivered by freight truck and moved right into my living room in three large, flat boxes.

Inside, when Mr. Cheap began unpacking them, we were pleasantly amazed at the amount of packing materials involved.

Those materials are:

  • Several long sheets of craft paper – quite rough, obviously recycled (these will turn into holiday wrapping paper  stamped with potato stamps before they are recycled).
  • Three long, slim pieces of styrofoam (about 2″ by 2′) and two square pieces of styrofoam (about 9″ square), both about 1/2″ thick. These will be recycled on a special trip to Eco-Cycle one day; meanwhile, they’ll join the rest of the difficult recyclables in a bag in my closet.
  • One square of cardboard folded into a rectangle — not even sealed with tape, but instead with grooves that fit into slots.
  • One long cardboard box that held the whole shebang.

The shelves themselves are pretty impressive, too. The notes on the item listing mention that the shelves are made of solid wood. The wood is pine (a fast-growing tree), and the composition is narrow strips of pine laminated together.

Lumber made from laminated wood has several benefits:

  • It reduces waste, because the flat portion of each board need only be 2″ wide or so, rather than 10″. This means manufacturers can use younger, faster-growing trees instead of old growth, and can use more of the tree instead of only the best part.
  • The resulting boards are stronger than a single board and less prone to warping from humidity and/or weight stress, especially when the direction of the grain alternates, as it does in the boards pictured above.

This type of wood also can have drawbacks, most seriously the glue used to create it. I tried very hard to get IKEA to explain to me what glue they use to assemble the shelves:

Q. The site said the bookcases are solid pine. I see they are actually laminated boards. This is fine, but we would like to know what adhesive is used to laminate the boards?

A. Here is a material description of the LEKSVIK bookcase.

Solid Pine: Wide, yellow/white graining with reddish heartwood. Pine is a rather soft kind of wood, and furniture may get pressure
marks.

Stain: A dye for coloring wood, which lets the grain shine through. Stain contains very carefully pulverized color pigment, but less than in usual paint.

Q. Thank you for your response. However … they are definitely NOT wide boards. They are made of narrow, 2″ boards laminated together into the width of the shelves and sides. This is fine, as it makes the wood stronger and is better for the environment. Our concern is that many laminated boards are constructed using formaldehyde-based resins. I am hoping IKEA would not use these types of resins, but I would like to know what is used to glue the boards together. I will attach a photo to show what I mean, in case there is some question. If I would do better to contact some other address, please let me know where to send my e-mail or call to get a response.

A. Formaldehyde is a gas, which occurs widely in nature.  It is, for example, naturally present is (sic) wood and fruit.  Formaldehyde is added to various products, such as adhesives, paints, varnishes and textiles.  High concentrations of formaldehyde can cause an allergic reaction. We have strict rules concerning formaldehyde, and we do not permit the use of paints and varnishes containing formaldehyde additives. For wooden products, we apply the German E1 standard and have done so for many years now. For textiles, we apply the Finnish regulations.  In both cases, these are currently the strictest within their field worldwide.

Glue is available in a great variety for different purposes.  White Glue (PVAC) is water-soluble and dries to give a colorless join.  It
is often used for furniture and is regarded as one of the most environmentally adapted glues currently available. Carbamide glue is used primarily for bonding veneer to particleboard.  Hot melt glue is used, for example, to fix edging strips to particleboard and to seal packaging.  Hot melt glue contains plastic.

Q. This does not quite answer my question. Please send a telephone number I could use to contact customer care.

A. [No answer.]

If I had to guess, based on the mysterious responses from IKEA, I would guess that the boards are laminated using carbamide resin, which sounds like it is essentially an organic product.

The shelves even come with a little groove cut out of the back to fit over our baseboard moulding, so they can stand flush against the wall. Mr. Cheap had to do a little bit of shimming & wiggling to get them to line up precisely even. But now there they are:

Shelves at left, with dog sleeping sitting up

Shelves at left, with our funny dog sleeping sitting up ... the better to admire them?

Ooh la la! IKEA, IKEA, where have you been all my life?

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “IKEA shelves packaged with minimal waste, no word on adhesives

  1. Melissa says:

    These shelves were beautiful in person, nice to know they were nicer than most products in packaging. Irritating you couldn’t get the answer you were looking for on adhesives.

  2. Sharon J says:

    I have Leksvik book shelves too (and a chest of drawers, coffee table and TV table) and although they’re now about five years old, they all still look as good as new. Well worth the money 🙂

  3. erin says:

    Hmmm…I know that IKEA has very strict environmental standards. I am sure the customer service guy was mentioning formaldehyde because I think they were the first company to ban it This was based on some issue with their Billy bookcases – one of those issues where they specified to not have it and then someone did independent testing and found it. This caused them to build stronger relationships with their suppliers and help them understand that IKEAs reputation is at stake because of the suppliers actions. Anyway – I am glad you are asking and it will be interesting to see if you can track down an answer. One thing I am wondering is if he did answer your question but you (and I) are not familiar enough with the German and Finnish standards.

  4. Cheap Like Me says:

    @Erin – I think they were telling me they don’t use formaldehyde glue, but I was looking for “the laminate in these shelves is XX.” I guess I am another victim of the computerized customer service culture … I don’t even know if real people were answering my question, or if a computer searched my question for keywords and then sent a response!

  5. Pam says:

    This was my reply from Ikea to my question about fire retardant fabric finishes and formaldehyde in adhesives and glues. Note they mention the ues of formaldehyde in their glue:

    Formaldehyde is a gas, which occurs widely in nature. It is, for example, naturally present is wood and fruit. Formaldehyde is added to various products, such as adhesives, paints, varnishes and textiles. High concentrations of formaldehyde can cause an allergic
    reaction.

    We have strict rules concerning formaldehyde, and we do not permit the use of paints and varnishes containing formaldehyde additives. For wooden products, we apply the German E1 standard and have done so for many years now.

    For textiles, we apply the Finish regulations. In both cases, these are currently the strictest within their field worldwide.

    Glue is available in a great variety for different purposes. White Glue (PVAC) is water-soluble and dries to give a colorless join. It is often used for furniture and is regarded as one of the most environmentally adapted glues currently available.

    The veneer is glued on the particle board with the same glue, meaning carbamide glue (urea formaldehyde glue). This is also the normal way of gluing veneer at furniture
    producers.

    Carbamide glue is used primarily for bonding veneer to particleboard. Hot melt glue is used, for example, to fix edging strips to particleboard and to seal packaging. Hot melt glue contains plastic.

    IKEA put strict demands on our suppliers which produce products with materials which contain formaldehyde. All materials have to comply with IKEA limits which are even
    stricter than legal limits. The IKEA formaldehyde demands means that the producers of material/production with formaldehyde, has to test the materials regularly and
    the production process has to be controlled and/or supervised by third part auditor. Apart from the third part auditing, our purchasing department visit the suppliers
    regularly and check that the furniture producers fulfills our
    demands.

    We do hope that this information has been helpful, and we thank you
    for your inquiry.

  6. cheaplikeme says:

    Oh, great. Thanks for the update! I like to think that my question helped inspire them to fill out their answer a bit more. 🙂 Or maybe my person just didn’t cut and paste the whole response …

Comments are closed.